The risk of hepatotoxicity is serious, but are the drugs to blame? It's easy to find opinions on the internet that cover the range of extremes. One website that sells herbal vitamins also urges customers to refrain from buying Tylenol or Nyquil because "THEY KILL!" (Broer, 2009). While it's true that these drugs can kill under certain circumstances, they are not dangerous if taken as recommended. Even herbal vitamins can be deadly if taken in excess.
Even if a drug itself is not dangerous, the packaging or directions may lead consumers to take more than the recommended dose. In July, the FDA announced a voluntary recall of concentrated acetaminophen drops because the packaging was similar to less-concentrated drops of the same brand, leading to "inadvertent overdosing" (FDA, 2009). In addition to recalling unsafe products, the FDA also takes a proactive approach to preventing hepatotoxicity. Earlier this year, the organization issued a rule that packaging for OTC pain relievers must conspicuously display warnings and active ingredients such as acetaminophen (FDA, 2009).
Although there are organizations in place to regulate drug safety, consumers should still be responsible when taking any medication. On the other side of the spectrum, there are those with an extremely lax attitude toward OTC drugs, which is an equally dangerous view. In a New York Times article from July, the author down-played the risk of acetaminophen hepatotoxicity by citing "only about 2,000 deaths" compared to the higher number of deaths linked to other pain relievers like aspirin, and a quote from a toxicologist implied that people should worry about ibuprofen, not acetaminophen (Parker-Pope, 2009).
It's best if consumers take a moderate approach to any medication, whether it be prescription, OTC, or herbal. They shouldn't avoid all drugs, but they also shouldn't be too careless.
References
Broer, T, (7-9-2009), http://www.healthmasters.com/blog/do-not-use-tylenol-or-nyquil-they-kill
Parker-Pope, T, (7-6-2009), http://www.nytimes.com/2009/07/07/health/ 07well.html
FDA, (7-13-2009), http://www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/ucm171780.htm
FDA, (4-28-2009), http://www.fda.gov/NewsEvents/Newsroom/PressAnnouncements/ucm149573.htm